Pre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl

S10 Ep20 MESSY JESSY VINTAGE: Jessica Barr, a Brooklyn-based dealer - on opening a collaborative vintage showroom and her unexpected, growing specialty in vintage bridal.

September 14, 2026·54 min
Episode Description from the Publisher

Today we're chatting with Jessica Barr, owner of Messy Jessy Vintage, a Brooklyn-based vintage brand specializing in women's wear and bridal, with a showroom she shares with two fellow dealers and a rotating presence at markets and events across New York, including the Manhattan Vintage Show.  Jessica studied journalism in school, and became fascinated with sustainability and inequality in fashion — studies that eventually led her to a dedicated practice of secondhand shopping and, not long after, selling vintage itself. Her real education in vintage came post-grad, working for Matt Smith at Newburgh Vintage Emporium, where she sharpened her eye for feminine silhouettes and fell hard for 1970s dresses. From there, her Etsy shop grew from a side hustle into a full-time business, eventually landing her in a Brooklyn showroom. In the last year, vintage bridal has become an unexpected and deeply personal part of her business, drawing in brides for laid-back appointments and building a community she never anticipated. We're getting into it all — the treasured thrift store finds, the incredible vintage buys from a theater's costume department, road trips across Massachusetts, and the labels and styles she can never resist. All that and more on today's show!  Let's dive right in! DISCUSSED IN THE EPISODE: [02:52] Jessica grew up loving fashion, including Jennifer Aniston street style and Phoebe from Friends, and hunting down pieces from Poshmark in high school  [04:45] She studied journalism in college with a focus on sustainability and inequality in fashion [08:25] Reconstructing a shredded 1980s Pink Floyd tee from the thrift store  [10:21] Working for Matt Smith at Newburgh Vintage Emporium post-graduation  [13:11] Developing her vintage brand's point of view: 70s dresses, cottagecore, feminine eveningwear  [14:39] How vintage bridal became part of the business, and selling her first wedding dress  [17:24] Balancing TikTok trends with personal sourcing vision  [19:16] Why her bridal content resonates so strongly  [23:37] Going full-time in vintage when she moved to Brooklyn, and the hustle of NYC's saturated but supportive vintage market  [27:56] Opening a shared Brooklyn showroom  [34:01] How her sourcing has shifted toward wholesale as the business has grown  [41:31] Holy grail finds and go-to labels [48:22] Favorite pieces from her personal collection, and her current vintage wishlist EPISODE MENTIONS:  Messy Jessy Vintage @messyjessyvintage Newburgh Vintage Emporium Matt Smith on Pre-Loved Podcast The Manhattan Vintage Show Armoury Shop Lucky Fool Vintage Studio Dorothy Brimfield Antique Flea Market LET'S CONNECT:  <li dir="ltr" role="presentation

Podzilla Summary coming soon

Sign up to get notified when the full AI-powered summary is ready.

Get Free Summaries →

Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.

Listen to This Episode

Get summaries like this every morning.

Free AI-powered recaps of Pre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl and your other favorite podcasts, delivered to your inbox.

Get Free Summaries →

Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.