Gary the Bigfoot Likes Oatmeal Cream Pies

Late-night host Walter Sterling breaks down the absurd, the controversial, and the downright bizarre on The Other Side of Midnight. In this episode, Walter tackles a story about a wealthy NYC columnist who forced her privileged daughter into a failing middle school as a social experiment—a decision Walter and callers slam as educational child abuse. Then, resident contributor Dr. Linda Salvin drops by with a wild report from Possum Creek, Ohio, where a 54-year-old woman claims she was romanced by Bigfoot ("Gary") and is carrying his child—until her mom reveals it was actually just a positive at-home COVID test. Plus, the show dives into how fatherhood shapes communities, why wearing a Brooks Brothers suit gets you upgraded to first class on flights, and proposed fixes for the public school system.