
In October I read that Mercedes has spent seven years cutting costs and watched its car margin fall anyway, from 12.6 percent in 2023 to 4 percent in the second quarter of this year. I read it the way a surgeon reads a file with his own initials in the margin.My job was headcount reduction, AK Reduzierung in German. My targets sat in maintenance and rework, Instandhaltung and Nacharbeit, across the German plants. McKinsey set the targets. I had done the same work at Chrysler, and I was good at it. The numbers came off the plants on schedule.His questionWhat I read was Sebastian Scheplitz’s essay in Contour Magazine, the best thing I have seen on the German car industry this year.He starts with the letter Mercedes sent its German staff in June: the hour of labor has to get cheaper, and the fairest way is for everyone to work more for the same money. Then he lays out seven years of cuts: a quarter of fixed costs gone since 2019, billions booked by a program called Next Level Performance. The margin fell anyway.His sharpest move is the van division. In the same quarter, Mercedes-Benz Vans earned 10.2 percent, out of German plants among others. Whatever Cars is missing, he concludes, you won’t find it on the payroll.He ends on a question he leaves open. What should that hour be building?I think I know. I spent a year and a half helping take it apart.Here is what I learned on the wrong side of the table. The ledger could see the price of an hour to the cent. It could not see what the hour formed: the people, and what they knew. So every cut I made was a drawdown of that capability, booked as savings. It worked once because the reservoir was full. It is failing now because it isn’t. That’s the argument.We did this beforeNothing Mercedes did this year is new.In 2004 a scheduled pay rise disappeared in a union deal, and planning and development went back to a 40-hour week. In February 2005 came a program called CORE: costs down, revenue up, execution. About 9,700 people took severance packages, and by the end of 2007 Mercedes reported 7.1 billion euros in savings and a margin back above 8 percent.My targets were part of CORE, and McKinsey ran the machine. Every vice president had a consultant in the office next to his. Zahlen, Daten, Fakten: numbers, data, facts. It was a PowerPoint machine, locked in large conference rooms, and the rest of us were the minions, reporting painful progress against committed targets. Everything in those rooms could be counted.I worked for Simon Boag, who ran Produktionsplanung, production planning, and Simon reported to Rainer Schmückle, the board member who ran operations for Mercedes cars. Simon, more alert than anyone to what the job demanded, insisted I learn to do it in German. He assigned me a private teacher, forty hours a week, weekends included, and I obliged. I delivered my report to Schmückle in German, my German, and closed the way every German presentation closes: Danke für Ihre Aufmerksamkeit. Thank you for your attention. He gave me a gentle nod.The nod meant one thing. Keep it up.It was the right nod. By every measure in the room, I was doing exactly what Mercedes needed.This year has a pay rise pushed back, the supervisory board chairman, Martin Brudermüller, calling for the 40-hour week, an exit program and a savings target. Same lever.The uncomfortable part: the first time, it worked.Why it worked onceTwo weeks ago I wrote about the near end of that system: the training centers where Germany forms its sixteen-year-olds, and the grey Meister shirt Herr Albrecht handed me on the crankshaft line at Untertürkheim. Albrecht told me then that if you respect the Instandhalter and reason with them, they answer with logic and care, and the business always gets better for it. He was describing a return on people.That return is why CORE worked. For decades, every maintenance crew and rework bay I was told to thin had been filled from those training centers. That was the reservoir. When you cut into a full reservoir, the level barely moves. The people left behind had been formed by the people you sent home, and they carried the load. The margin came back. The spreadsheet looked brilliant, and so did I.Nobody wrote down what we had drawn out.The ledger that wasn’t thereMaintenance and rework are where a plant keeps what it hasn’t written down. Maintenance is where somebody knows why a machine faults. Rework is where somebody knows where a defect was born. That knowledge is formed slowly, person to person. It isn’t taught in a classroom, and nobody counts it.In the giant Halle at Sindelfingen where the E-Class is built, I went to the repair bays. Dozens of cars stood open, and craftsmen peered into them, finishing their repairs at a pace entirel
Podzilla Summary coming soon
Sign up to get notified when the full AI-powered summary is ready.
Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.

Simone Weil. Saint.

What's This We?

The Ledger Hides the Graduate

Contractors Aren't Buying Robots
Free AI-powered recaps of The Long Game for All: Counting What Frontlines Know and your other favorite podcasts, delivered to your inbox.
Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.