Is Abortion Murder? A Rabbi Debates a Jewish Pro-Life Leader

#AbortionDebate #ProChoice #ProLifeIs abortion murder—and what does Judaism actually teach about abortion?In this thought-provoking episode of The Fifth Question Podcast, Rabbi Daniel Levine sits down with Cecily Routman, founder and president of the Jewish Pro-Life Foundation, for a candid debate about abortion, Jewish law, morality, medical ethics, and public policy.They examine biblical and rabbinic sources—including Genesis, Exodus, the Mishnah, Talmud, the Noahide laws, and the concept of the rodef—while debating whether Jewish tradition considers abortion to be murder, a lesser prohibition, or a permissible act under certain circumstances.The conversation explores:• Is abortion permitted under Jewish law?• Does Judaism consider a fetus a full human life?• How should Exodus 21:22–23 be interpreted?• What does the Mishnah teach when a pregnancy threatens the mother?• Does protecting the mother’s life justify abortion?• Are cases involving rape, incest, fetal abnormalities, or severe psychological distress treated differently?• Can traditional Jewish teachings be separated from modern politics?• When does human life—and moral personhood—begin?• How should religious belief influence abortion laws in America?Rabbi Levine challenges the claim that Judaism is unequivocally opposed to abortion, while Routman argues that protecting unborn life is fundamental to Torah ethics. The result is a passionate and sometimes tense exchange between two sharply different interpretations of Jewish tradition.Whether you identify as pro-life, pro-choice, religious, secular, Jewish, or simply interested in abortion ethics, this episode offers an in-depth look at one of the most controversial moral and political debates of our time.Watch the full conversation, share your perspective respectfully in the comments, and subscribe to The Fifth Question Podcast for more honest discussions about Judaism, religion, ethics, politics, and culture.#AbortionDebate #IsAbortionMurder #Judaism #JewishLaw #ProLife #ProChoice #Abortion #Torah #Talmud #MedicalEthics #ReligiousDebate #JewishPodcast #TheFifthQuestionPodcast