Family Bracket Challenge Reveals Stewart's Best Flavor | Stay Outta My Fridge

Stewart's Ice Cream Bracket Challenge is finally here! Avery and Isla join Beard Laws as we raid the freezer, grab 8 random Stewart's Ice Cream pints, and put them through the ultimate taste test tournament to crown the best Stewart's ice cream flavor. From Cookies & Cream and Moose Trail to Happy Camper, Bark in the Dark, Sugar Shack Swirl, and more, every flavor had to survive our family bracket challenge. Some favorites dominated, some surprise underdogs pulled off huge upsets, and one Stewart's Ice Cream flavor walked away as champion. If you're a Stewart's Shops fan, ice cream lover, or someone searching for the best Stewart's ice cream flavor, this episode is for you. What's In The Fridge This Week? • Stewart's Ice Cream taste test • Family food challenge and bracket tournament • Honest snack review and flavor rankings • Taste Test 2026 family edition • Funny family food vlog moments This week we headed to Stewart's Shops in Heuvelton, New York and took advantage of their pint sale. With limited flavors available, we randomly selected eight different Stewart's Ice Cream pints and built a March Madness-style bracket to determine which flavor deserves the crown. Would Cookies & Cream live up to the hype? Could Bark in the Dark pull off a massive upset? Would Happy Camper make us happy? Or would a dark horse flavor steal the championship? You'll have to watch to find out. Stay Outta My Fridge is the show where the kids take over the kitchen. Join Beard Laws, Avery, and Isla for the most chaotic food reviews on the internet. Every week we test snacks, drinks, candy, fast food, desserts, and weird food finds while sharing funny family moments along the way. Timestamps 00:00 - Introduction to Stuart's ice cream tasting challenge 00:31 - Overview of flavors and sale context 01:00 - Ice cream favorites and personal preferences 02:26 - Description of the ice cream flavors and selection process 03:53 - First impressions and ranking methodology 04:50 - Tasting and ranking chocolate peanut butter cup vs. salty caramel gelato 05:49 - Discussion on texture and flavor; non-dairy options 06:17 - Comparison of Moose Trail, Bark in the Dark, and vanilla 07:10 - Final ranking predictions and bracket seedings 08:07 - Tasting matchups: peanut butter cup vs. Bark in the Dark 09:06 - Head-to-head taste tests and bracket organization 10:28 - Final bracket seeding and matchup setup 11:26 - First round taste-off analysis: chocolate peanut butter cup vs. Bark in the Dark 12:52 - Flavor profiles and preference weighing 15:00 - Second matchup: cookies and cream vs. gelato 16:23 - Taste test and ranking decision; winner advances 17:30 - Vanilla vs. Sugar Shack; debate over maple versus plain vanilla 19:27 - Sugar Shack's victory and next round matchup against Moose Trails 22:38 - Moose vs. Happy Camper; taste test and preferences 24:37 - Final matchup: cookies and cream vs. Sugar Shack 26:33 - Final voting and championship decision 29:48 - Elation and reflection on the winning flavor 30:48 - Overall favorites and honorable mentions 32:43 - Closing thoughts, upcoming episodes, and special shoutouts A proud production of the Beard Laws Network. New Stay Outta My Fridge episodes every Thursday — subscribe and join the family! #StayOuttaMyFridge #StewartsIceCream #BeardLawsNetwork #FoodReview #FamilyVlog If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe and leave a 5-star review on your favorite podcast app! It's the best way to help our family show reach more people.This has been The Stay Outta My Fridge Podcast, your source for family comedy, snack reviews, and '90s nostalgia.Find us on social media The Stay Outta My Fridge Podcast is a part of the Bleav Network. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.