
A conversation with Jared Bernstein and Jason FurmanMarketing note: I have a new ebook, Navigating the Chaos: Chronicles of Economic and Political Madness, which uses material from this Substack to construct a thematic narrative of the past two years and the issues that Democrats must now address to build an enduring progressive movement. Available from Amazon, Kobo, Bookshop, and Nook.. . .TRANSCRIPT: Paul Krugman in Conversation with Jared Bernstein and Jason Furman(recorded 11/12/26)Paul Krugman: Today I’m talking with Jared Bernstein and Jason Furman, both of whom have been writing, as I have, about AI. Is it a bubble? If it is a bubble, what happens when it bursts? What’s it doing to the economy? All things AI. Hopefully, we can stay off of honeypots for the most part. But is it a bubble? I am surprisingly uncertain in my own judgment here. So, we can talk about the scope of it, but what can we make of this huge, huge investment in a very new technology?Jared Bernstein: Well, when I’m being disciplined, I describe it as probably a bubble. I should start out by saying almost everything I’m going to say for the next X minutes is going to be speculative. And also, I’d like to underscore that, for all my concerns about a bubble and a bubble bursting, I think AI is likely to be a significant productivity enhancer, perhaps even transformational in that regard. So I don’t want to lose that. But in terms of your basic question, my work on this is with Ryan Cummings, and we started sniffing a bubble in the sector over a year ago, and we had a piece in The New York Times to that effect. We thought that the gap between the spend of the hyperscalers and the labs—the actual spending that they were doing and the expected spending—the gap between that and plausible earnings projections suggested bubble dynamics. So in later work, we were able to roughly quantify that gap. And others did a similar exercise. And I know you, Paul in particular, you’ve written about that. There’s a Brookings paper on this, which further raised our bubble antennae.Actually, at this point, the diagnosis is pretty widely agreed upon, although there are doubts. And I share yours as well, Paul, with the added worry—now, this wasn’t quite there when we first started writing in October of last year—of leverage, that is. A lot of the spend was initially financed through cash flow. And some of these companies have big cash flows—not the freestanding labs, but the Metas and the Amazons—and now there’s the added worry of leverage because there’s so much more borrowing.Last point on this: I do think it’s a good question for people who have the position I have as to whether you’ve personally divested in the sector. And I will say that I partially have, in that there is no SpaceX in my portfolio at this point in time.Krugman: Let me ask you, Jason, for your take. I have some thoughts also.Jason Furman: Well, first of all, I’ll do the investment advice first. All of my financial assets are basically in Vanguard Global ETF. So I have every single company on the planet Earth, or at least I aspire to have every single company on planet Earth. And so in that sense, I think with the sort of “your money’s where your mouth is” test, I’m implicitly saying it’s not a bubble.I wake up different days taking different sides of this argument. It doesn’t feel like this is the type of network that previous technologies were—like Google Search becoming the best, or Facebook becoming the best. Everyone basically needed to use it, and they could end up with, in the case of Google, 90% of the search market. For this, I can use Claude, you can use ChatGPT, and I know Jared is just obsessed with Grok—maybe I wasn’t supposed to tell people that, Jared?—but it
Podzilla Summary coming soon
Sign up to get notified when the full AI-powered summary is ready.
Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.

Paul Krugman and Heather Cox Richardson in Conversation | CUNY Graduate Center

Climates of Treason

Azeem Azhar on the Explosion of Hacking and Other AI Issues

The Starlink-Ukraine Scandal, Phase 2
Free AI-powered recaps of Paul Krugman Podcast and your other favorite podcasts, delivered to your inbox.
Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.