
Happy Friday!Thank you for a strong start to the second quarter as we work toward our performance targets. Last week, we took an honest look at our first-quarter attendance and behavior numbers, and this week our work turned toward the people behind those numbers. Our elementary teachers spent time face to face with families, our classrooms continue with expectations, and our buildings began the second quarter with a clear sense of where to focus.This week, I want to share something our district leadership team has been reading and thinking about together. It concerns one of the most common tools in every classroom, and it asks us to be thoughtful about how and when we use it.Screens, Learning, and PurposeThis fall, the district leadership team is reading The Digital Delusion by neuroscientist Jared Cooney Horvath. The book argues that the heavy use of laptops, tablets, and classroom software is weakening the way children learn and develop. Several of its concerns are worth sharing with every member of our staff.* Engagement is not the same as learning. Fast, flashy digital tools can hold a student’s attention without building lasting understanding. A student who is busy on a screen is not always a student who is learning.* Devices invite drift. According to the research the book reviews, students using classroom devices can be off task for as much as 38 minutes of every hour.* Paper and pencil still matter. Students understand what they read better on paper than on a screen, and handwritten notes produce better recall than typed notes.* More screen time tracks with lower scores. On international assessments, students who use computers more than six hours a day score far below students who do not use them at all, a gap of roughly two letter grades.The book is not a call to get rid of technology. Learning to type, building a spreadsheet, or practicing a skill that truly belongs on a computer are good uses of a screen. The question is whether a device is the best tool for the learning in front of us or simply the most convenient one.We began reducing screen time as a district before we ever opened this book. Bell to Bell, No Cell took personal phones out of the school day. We have been doing this for more than two years now, and we have encouraged everyone to reduce screen time for students and increase the amount of handwriting they do. The reading confirms that we are on the right path, but it also reminds us that this work is decided in each classroom, not in a policy.Please monitor how much time students spend on devices. Use devices on purpose, when they are the best tool for the task, and do not let them become the default for every learning activity. Reading from a printed page, writing by hand, working a problem on paper, and talking through an idea with a classmate and a teacher remain some of the most powerful learning experiences we can offer.A Different View Than a Decade AgoThis is a real change in thinking for our profession. In 2008, it was widely predicted that half of all high school courses would be delivered online by 2019, and a decade ago many educators believed that prediction was on track. Online learning was expected to become the primary way students learned, and many of us assumed more technology would naturally mean more learning.The results did not support that belief. Even before the pandemic, a national study found that students in full-time online schools gained the equivalent of 180 fewer days of learning in math and 72 fewer days in reading each year than similar students in traditional schools.The pandemic made the cost impossible to ignore. A study of more than two million students in 49 states found that students who spent more of the 2020–2021 school year in remote instruction grew far less than students in earlier years, and the losses were steepest in high-poverty communities. Where schools returned to in-person learning sooner, the losses were smaller. Recovery from those years is still part of our work today.The lesson is not that technology is bad. The lesson is that learning is a human activity. It grows through relationships, focus, conversation, and effort. When we put people before programs, our devices become what they should be: tools that serve our teachers and students rather than replace them.I say all of this as someone who once held the opposite view. When I was in the classroom, I was a technology enthusiast and an early adopter. I was often the first to t
Podzilla Summary coming soon
Sign up to get notified when the full AI-powered summary is ready.
Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.
Free AI-powered recaps of Bearcat Wrap-up Podcast and your other favorite podcasts, delivered to your inbox.
Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.