
Free Daily Podcast Summary
by Monique Sanchez and Amy Traydon
Looking for a true crime and paranormal podcast that isn’t murder to get through? Check out “Another F*cking Horror Podcast.” Each week, bffs Monique Sanchez and Amy Traydon deliver a fun and expletive-filled spin on lesser-known true tales of murder, mayhem, and things that will leave you saying “what the actual f*ck?” Is it safe for work? Should you listen to it in the car with the kids? F*ck no! It’s “Another F*cking Horror Podcast.”
The most recent episodes — sign up to get AI-powered summaries of each one.
This week on Another F*cking Horror Podcast, Monique and Amy officially embrace spooky season with a haunted hospital basement, a Texas bar owner with a backyard full of alligators and enough deeply questionable decisions to make “just keep walking and don’t look back” feel like solid life advice. First, Monique takes us down to Minus Two, the mortuary level of a hospital in Northern England where a porter named Ray has spent more than two decades transporting bodies through a long, windowless basement corridor. Older staff have one very specific rule: never whistle on the way to the mortuary. Ray never did, but that apparently didn’t stop something from showing up anyway. One night, the lights change, the temperature drops, his gurney suddenly becomes impossible to push and he hears breathing right beside him. Because apparently transporting dead bodies alone at night wasn’t unsettling enough already. Then Amy heads to 1930s Elmendorf, Texas, for the story of Joseph D. Ball, a World War I veteran, bootlegger and owner of the Sociable Inn. And because a regular Texas saloon apparently wasn’t enough of a business model, Joe kept a pool of live alligators behind the bar and entertained customers by feeding them live animals. Then women connected to Joe started disappearing. After police finally came asking questions, Joe took his own life, and the investigation that followed uncovered the murders of Minnie Gotthardt and Hazel Brown. But if you’ve heard the legend of the “Alligator Man” who murdered women and fed their bodies to his gators, things get complicated. Only two murders were confirmed, several supposedly missing women were later found alive and no human remains were discovered in the alligator pond. Over the years, pulp magazines, rumors and increasingly fucked up retellings turned an already horrifying true crime case into something even more sensational. Because apparently two murdered women, a bloody axe and five backyard alligators weren’t enough for people. So, yes. This one has haunted hospital corridors, mortuary superstitions, disembodied breathing, murder, alligators, Depression era Texas chaos and the very important reminder that if an older hospital employee tells you not to whistle in the mortuary, maybe just fucking listen. Watch On YouTube! Join Our Patreon For Uncensored Video Episodes! Check Out Our Website! Follow Us On Instagram!
After reflecting on some of our recent losses, Amy honors perfect human angel, Dolly Rebecca Parton by recounting some of her celebrity ghost stories and confirming that Dolly was one of us. Then, in the morning hours of Wednesday, April 3, 1935, Herbert Hurd shot and killed his wife, Nellie, in what seemed like an open and shut case. But buckle your seatbelts, kids, as Monique unravels one of the most bizarre true crime stories in Kansas City, MO history. If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe. Watch On YouTube! Join Our Patreon! Check Out Our Website! Follow Us On Instagram!
The girls are back, and this week’s episode is a perfect little haunted-theater, true-crime anxiety spiral. Cute? No. Creepy? Extremely. First, Monique tells the story of British comedian Jason Manford, who got cast in the West End revival of Sweeney Todd at London’s historic Adelphi Theatre. Every night after getting his throat slashed onstage, Jason would clean off the fake blood and FaceTime his wife and twin daughters before bed. How sweet. Until his three-year-old daughter asked, “Daddy, who’s that man behind you?” A tall man with dark hair, a mustache, and a soldier’s uniform: a description that matched William Terriss, the beloved Victorian actor who was stabbed to death at the Adelphi stage door in 1897 while wearing a Union Army captain’s costume. The theatre ghosts really said: yes, and? Then Amy brings us into the 1977 death of Charles “Chuck” Morgan, a Tucson escrow company president whose case is so suspicious it feels personally insulting that anyone tried to rule it as a suicide. Chuck disappeared, came home three days later missing a shoe, bound in plastic handcuffs, unable to speak and writing that he had been kidnapped and tortured. He hinted at a secret government identity, got paranoid (naturally), wore a bulletproof vest, carried a gun and told his family he had written a letter naming who was responsible if anything happened to him. Then he disappeared again. Nine days later, a mystery woman called “Green Eyes” phoned his wife with an ominous Bible passage and soon after, Chuck was found in the desert wearing his bulletproof vest, shot in the back of the head, with a $2 bill pinned to his underwear and absolutely no reasonable explanation. Police ruled it suicide. Monique and Amy, correctly, said: no, girl, no. If you take anything away from this episode, let it be this: when a three-year-old sees a crying soldier behind you, maybe believe the fucking child.
The girls are back, and this episode starts in full spooky mode before Monique makes a hard left into Victorian women eating arsenic wafers for a glow up. First, Amy tells the story of Ivy Sundarji, a hardcore skeptic, atheist and science-minded TV writer who starts hearing from her late fiancé Jahangir after he drowns in the exact surfing accident she had once seen in a vision. And then a little blonde girl shows up. She says “Daddy did it.” She shows Ivy images, names, places and details that later connect to the case of five-year-old Harmony Montgomery. Ivy, who very much does not want to be “some crazy lady in Los Angeles” calling a tip line about a dead child talking to her, does it anyway. Because looking dumb matters less than justice. Then Monique goes rogue (as she should) with a deeply upsetting Victorian death-and-beauty deep dive. We’re talking tuberculosis, the White Death, lead face enamel, mercury creams, belladonna eye drops, radium products and arsenic complexion wafers sold like they were cute little wellness snacks. This one is grief, ghosts, the horrors of beauty and two best friends asking, very correctly: what the fuck is wrong with people?
The girls aren’t the only ones with terrifying tales. Everyone’s got something to say on this True Listener Tales edition #43, as the listeners say, “Hey, here’s the most traumatic thing that ever happened to me”. This round starts with a fake dead mom prank. Caveat: that’s not a prank, that’s psychological warfare. Then we get a Ouija board sleepover, a ghost named Rasha, a bathroom mirror, vomiting and a smiling figure in the hallway. From there, the stories keep escalating because apparently everybody decided to submit from the devil’s group chat. We get a grandfather’s final goodbye, a ghost light being hurled across a theater, Sergio praying over Jane and getting grabbed by something with inhuman strength, Bala speaking in his dead uncle’s voice at a funeral, a Tombstone tipping table with attitude, demonic grandparents eating some bloody red thing, Maeve’s glitch-walking shadow creature, and Anthony’s near-death experience after being hit by a car. Not sure this is the kind of “list is endless” moment we want but it’s what we’ve got. Heebie-jeebies maxxing, anyone?
The girls are back, and this time, to ask two very reasonable questions. One, why would you invite a Gettysburg ghost into your home. And, two, why does the Christopher Nolan brother rumor have so much truth to it? First, Monique tells the story of Trina, a skeptic who went on a Gettysburg ghost tour during her honeymoon, mocked the whole thing and then jokingly invited an entity home like it was a refrigerator magnet. Her husband told her to take it back but she just had to double down. The haunting that followed was water-based and weirdly poetic: scalding showers, exploding water, light bulbs burning out near sinks, CPAP issues, pneumonia that made her feel like she was drowning, and eventually a black shadow figure sliding across the floor toward a pond. Lesson: respect the dead. Then Amy takes us into the real story behind the viral rumor about Christopher Nolan’s “fugitive hitman brother.” The truth is messier: Matthew Nolan, the filmmaker’s older brother, allegedly used the alias Matthew Oppenheimer while posing as an heir to the Oppenheimer diamond fortune. That alias pulled him into the orbit of Robert Cohen, a tax accountant tied to missing money, fake passports, a kidnapping, a brutal murder, an Interpol red notice, a prison escape plan, and a justice system that somehow still left Cohen’s daughter without the accountability she deserved. This one has a strong AFHP moral of the story: stop being shitty while you’re alive, because neither ghosts nor consequences are ever impressed with that behavior.
The girls are back with an episode that starts with mystical Russian Orthodox nightmare fuel and ends with Argentina turning a serial killer into Friendship Day merch. Totally normal. First, Amy tells the story of Mia and James, a mysterious ex-boyfriend from an Otherworld Patreon story who casually claimed he could have the dreams of people he slept next to. Cute first date chat? No, thank you. Then he accurately described Mia’s lifelong recurring childhood nightmare, the one she had never told anyone about, and somehow, after that, the nightmare stopped. And if that wasn’t enough, Mia later saw James’s body in a mirror with a completely different old man’s face, and when James told his therapist, she admitted she had seen the same man too. Then Monique takes us to Buenos Aires for the story of Yiya Murano, the so-called Poisoner of Montserrat, a woman obsessed with status, elegance and living like a socialite on money she did not have. After running a Ponzi scheme on her friends, Yiya allegedly solved her little financial problem by poisoning three women with cyanide. And somehow, after prison, Argentina said: we have a new pop culture icon. We’re talking TV appearances, mugs, memes and musicals. This episode has dream stealing, hooved angel warnings, poisoned pastries and a whole lot of “what the fuck?”
The girls are back with a birthday episode, and they’re giving “rager” a new meaning as they travel from “maybe aliens snatched this man’s plane” to “the U.S. Navy really said racism? never heard of her.” First, Monique gives Amy the birthday gift of a deeply weird UFO disappearance: the 1978 case of Frederick Valentich, a 20-year-old Australian pilot who vanished over the Bass Strait after reporting a strange object hovering above him. His final transmission included the words “it’s not an aircraft,” followed by 17 seconds of creepy mechanical noise and then absolutely fucking nothing. Then Amy takes us into the Port Chicago disaster, one of the worst homefront disasters of World War II and a story so enraging it should come with a free blood pressure cuff. Black sailors were forced to load explosives without proper training, officers turned it into a speed competition, 320 people were killed in a massive blast and then the Navy blamed the surviving Black sailors when they refused to go back to the same deadly work. It took 80 years for the Port Chicago 50 and other convicted sailors to be exonerated.
Free AI-powered daily recaps. Key takeaways, quotes, and mentions — in a 5-minute read.
Get Free Summaries →Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.
Listeners also like.

Crimehub: A True Crime Podcast
Examines disturbing and unbelievable true crimes from modern history with in-depth storytelling and new cases released weekly.

Murder, Mystery & Makeup
A beauty influencer explores true crime stories, from serial killers to cannibals, while doing makeup.

Haunting
Real-life paranormal encounters told through immersive first-hand stories hosted by a ghost navigating the afterlife.

Murder In America
A true crime podcast exploring infamous homicides in each U.S. state, blending investigative analysis with paranormal insights.

Two Girls One Ghost
Two friends explore supernatural stories with research and listener submissions, blending the eerie and unexplained.

Into The Dark
Explores true crime cases, conspiracy theories, and paranormal mysteries while examining the psychology behind human behavior.

True Crime Garage
Two hosts analyze real crime cases weekly, blending detailed research with casual conversation over beer.

Something Scary
Ghost stories, urban legends, and folktales from around the world are explored through eerie, ad-free storytelling.

Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast
Two Florida moms examine true crime cases from Florida and beyond, exploring how each event occurred with candid, conversational analysis.

And That's Why We Drink
A weekly podcast blending true crime and paranormal stories with humor and casual commentary.

Morbid
A true crime and spooky history podcast blending research and dark humor, hosted by an autopsy technician and a hairstylist.

True Crime Tonight
Five nights a week, a deep dive into true crime cases, celebrity scandals, and trials with analysis and listener discussions.
Looking for a true crime and paranormal podcast that isn’t murder to get through? Check out “Another F*cking Horror Podcast.” Each week, bffs Monique Sanchez and Amy Traydon deliver a fun and expletive-filled spin on lesser-known true tales of murder, mayhem, and things that will leave you saying “what the actual f*ck?” Is it safe for work? Should you listen to it in the car with the kids? F*ck no! It’s “Another F*cking Horror Podcast.”
AI-powered recaps with compact key takeaways, quotes, and insights.
Get key takeaways from Another Fucking Horror Podcast in a 5-minute read.
Stay current on your favorite podcasts without falling behind.
It's a free AI-powered email that summarizes new episodes of Another Fucking Horror Podcast as soon as they're published. You get the key takeaways, notable quotes, and links & mentions — all in a quick read.
When a new episode drops, our AI transcribes and analyzes it, then generates a personalized summary tailored to your interests and profession. It's delivered to your inbox every morning.
No. Podzilla is an independent service that summarizes publicly available podcast content. We're not affiliated with or endorsed by Monique Sanchez and Amy Traydon.
Absolutely! The free plan covers up to 3 podcasts. Upgrade to Pro for 15, or Premium for 50. Browse our full catalog at /podcasts.
Another Fucking Horror Podcast publishes weekly. Our AI generates a summary within hours of each new episode.
Another Fucking Horror Podcast covers topics including True Crime. Our AI identifies the specific themes in each episode and highlights what matters most to you.
Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.
Free forever for up to 3 podcasts. No credit card required.